Indian environmentalist Dr. Vandana Shiva tears into misleading New Yorker article


VShivaIn her response to the article ‘Seeds of Doubt’ by Michael Specter in The New Yorker, Indian environmentalist Dr. Vandana Shiva has taken to task the writer of the piece, Mr. Specter, for misleading the readers of the esteemed magazine with ‘many fraudulent assertions and deliberate attempts to skew reality’.

In a long piece on her own website, she says:

“I wonder why a journalist who has been Bureau Chief in Moscow for The New York Times and Bureau Chief in New York for the Washington Post, and clearly is an experienced reporter, would submit such a misleading piece. Or why The New Yorker would allow it to be published as honest reporting, with so many fraudulent assertions and deliberate attempts to skew reality. ‘Seeds of Doubt’ contains many lies and inaccuracies that range from the mundane (we never met in a café but in the lobby of my hotel where I had just arrived from India to attend a High Level Round Table for the post 2015 SDGs of the UN) to grave fallacies that affect people’s lives. The piece has now become fodder for the social media supporting the Biotech Industry. Could it be that rather than serious journalism, the article was intended as a means to strengthen the biotechnology industry’s push to ‘engage consumers’? Although creative license is part of the art of writing, Michael Specter cleverly takes it to another level, by assuming a very clear position without spelling it out.”

Read More